Last seen wearing a mustard yellow hoodie, black pants and a maroon backpack shortly before noon on Sunday, December 22, 2019. Allyson has a tattoo of an eye on her front left shoulder area and a tattoo of a fairy sitting on a spider web on her left forearm.
She was last seen with her boyfriend, Benjamin Garland, 21. A homeowner found Garland asleep in his truck on the morning of Dec. 23, and his father, Don Garland, reported Watterson missing on Dec. 23, about 30 hours after she was last seen. Garland has since been arrested on charges unrelated to Watterson’s disappearance, including fraudulent use of a credit card and possession of a stolen vehicle.